Unit 227: Pythagorean Theorem and Irrational Numbers

Day 12 of 30

Visual proofs of the Pythagorean theorem

6-8Mathematics

Lessons are AI-drafted and being reviewed and improved over time.

Learning Objective

Explain a visual proof of the Pythagorean theorem by finding the area of one large square in two different ways.

Today's Lesson

Yesterday you tested the Pythagorean theorem on a few triangles. Testing is helpful, but it is not a proof. A proof shows that a rule must be true for every right triangle, not just the ones you tried. Some of the best proofs of this theorem are visual. They use pictures and area instead of long chains of algebra.

Here is one well-known visual proof. Take four copies of the same right triangle. Call the legs a and b and the hypotenuse c. Draw a large square whose sides are each a + b long. Now place the four triangles inside it, one in each corner, so that each side of the large square is made of one short leg and one long leg. The triangles leave a tilted shape in the middle. Each side of that shape is a hypotenuse, so every side has length c.

Why is the middle shape a square and not just a diamond? Look at a point where two triangles meet along a side of the large square. The two acute angles of a right triangle add to 90 degrees. Those two angles sit beside the corner of the middle shape on a straight line, and a straight line makes 180 degrees. That leaves 180 - 90 = 90 degrees for the corner. All four corners are right angles, so the middle shape is a square with area c².

Now count the area of the large square two ways. First, its side is a + b, so its area is (a + b) × (a + b). Second, it is made of four triangles plus the middle square. Each triangle has area one half of a × b. Both counts describe the same square, so they must be equal.

A second way to see it keeps the same large square but moves the triangles. Slide them into pairs so that each pair forms a rectangle. The two rectangles fill two corners, and the empty space left over is one square of side a and one square of side b. The triangles cover the same area in both pictures, so the empty space must be the same too. In the first picture the empty space is c². In the second it is a² + b². So a² + b² = c².

Try it with numbers. Use legs of 3 and 4. The large square has side 7 and area 49. The four triangles each have area 6, for a total of 24. The middle square has area 49 - 24 = 25, so c = 5. The proof did not depend on 3 and 4, which is why it works for any right triangle.

Visual proofs reward careful looking. Ask yourself what stays the same when pieces move. Area does not change when a shape slides or turns.

Key Terms
Proof

An argument that shows a statement must be true in every case, not just the cases tested.

Visual proof

A proof that uses a picture and reasoning about area or shape to show a statement is true.

Rearrangement

Moving pieces of a figure to new positions without changing their size or shape.

Acute angle

An angle that measures less than 90 degrees.

Area conservation

The idea that a figure keeps the same area when its pieces are slid, turned, or flipped.

Activities
Instructions
1. Use the pre-cut set of four matching paper right triangles with legs of 6 cm and 8 cm. 2. Draw a 14 cm by 14 cm square on paper. 3. Arrange the triangles inside the square so a tilted square is left in the middle, and trace the empty space. 4. Rearrange the triangles into two rectangles in opposite corners, and trace the two empty squares. 5. Find the area of each empty space and write two sentences explaining why the totals must match.
Materials Needed
  • Four pre-cut paper right triangles (6 cm and 8 cm legs)
  • Plain paper
  • Ruler
  • Colored pencils
Practice Problems
1

In the visual proof of the Pythagorean theorem with legs 3 and 4, the large square has side 7. Find the area of the large square, the four triangles, and the middle square.

Hint: Each triangle has area one half of 3 × 4.
2

Repeat the visual proof with legs of 5 and 12. What is the hypotenuse?

Hint: The large square has side 5 + 12.
3

Use the same proof picture with legs 6 and 8. Show that the middle square has area 100.

Hint: Start with a large square of side 14.
4

Priya builds the visual proof with legs 1 and 2. What is the exact length of the hypotenuse?

Hint: The large square has side 3.
5

In the proof, why must the middle shape be a square and not just a diamond with four equal sides?

Hint: Think about the two acute angles of a right triangle and a straight line.
6

Dev says checking ten triangles counts as a proof of the theorem. Explain why the visual proof is stronger.

Hint: Does the area argument depend on particular numbers?

Teaching Tip

Physical triangles make the rearrangement click. Have students say aloud what stays the same when pieces move. Advanced students can expand (a + b)² = a² + 2ab + b² and cancel 2ab, but the area picture is the core goal.

Go Deeper

Research the trapezoid proof published by James Garfield in 1876 and compare its picture with the four-triangle proof.

AI Tutor

Coming later.